Skip to content

Blog / Notices

Rule 86B: when 1% must be paid in cash

6 min readNotices

Most GST payments are a mix: output tax is first set off against input tax credit (ITC), and the balance is paid in cash. Rule 86B of the CGST Rules puts a ceiling on how much of the output tax you can pay using ITC. In short: Where the taxable value of supplies in a month (other than exempt and zero-rated supplies) exceeds Rs 50 lakh, at least 1% of the output tax liability must be paid in cash, unless an exception applies. One exception is cumulative cash paid, up to the month, of more than 1% of the total output tax liability for the year.

What the rule says, in plain terms

If the value of your taxable supplies in a month, other than exempt supplies and zero-rated supplies, is more than ₹50 lakh, then you cannot use the electronic credit ledger to pay more than 99% of your output tax liability for that month. The remaining 1% has to be paid from the electronic cash ledger.

Three details matter.

  • It is a monthly test, per registration. Each GSTIN is tested on its own supplies, not as a group.
  • The threshold is on taxable supplies. Exempt supplies and zero-rated supplies are left out of the ₹50 lakh calculation.
  • Reverse charge liability is outside the cap. Tax payable under reverse charge has always been payable in cash, and it is treated separately.

A quick example

Suppose your taxable supplies in a month are ₹80 lakh and your output tax on them is ₹10 lakh. Rule 86B limits the credit you can use to 99% of ₹10 lakh, which is ₹9.9 lakh. The remaining ₹10,000 must be paid in cash, even if your credit ledger has enough balance to cover everything.

If your credit ledger would have covered all ₹10 lakh, the rule still forces ₹10,000 into the cash ledger. Over a year, that is a permanent cash cost, not a timing difference, unless you later receive a refund or adjust against future liabilities.

Who is exempt

The rule lists situations in which the restriction does not apply. In summary, it does not apply if any of the following is true.

  • Income tax paid: the registered person, or in specified cases its proprietor, karta, managing director or partners, has paid income tax of more than ₹1 lakh in each of the last two financial years for which the time to file the return has expired.
  • Refund of unutilised ITC: the registered person received a refund of more than ₹1 lakh in the preceding financial year on account of unutilised ITC, for example under zero-rated supplies or an inverted duty structure.
  • Cumulative cash payment: the taxpayer has paid, in cash, more than 1% of the total output tax liability cumulatively up to the month in the current year (second proviso, clause (d)). The base is output tax, not turnover: taxable supplies matter only for the ₹50 lakh threshold.
  • Specified entities: the registered person is a government department, a public sector undertaking, a local authority or a statutory body.

There is also a provision for an officer to remove the restriction after satisfying themselves, on a case-by-case basis. A taxpayer in any of these positions should keep the evidence on file, because the rule is applied through the portal and an error can block a return.

Note that the exceptions depend on facts that live outside GST: income tax paid by the proprietor or partners, for example. A team handling the GST should ask the business for the figures early in the year and not discover the issue at month-end.

How it shows up in GSTR-3B

When you file GSTR-3B, the system checks whether the payment of tax through credit would breach the cap. If it would, the portal may not let you offset liability in full with the credit ledger. In practice you see a shortfall in the cash payment column. If you have not planned for it, you face either a late scramble to deposit cash or a delayed filing, and delayed filing brings late fee and interest.

Planning to avoid surprises

  1. Know which side of the line you are on. Check, each month, whether taxable supplies are likely to cross ₹50 lakh for each GSTIN.
  2. Check the exceptions at the start of the year. If the income tax test or the cumulative 1% test is likely to be met, record the evidence.
  3. Estimate cash before you file. Take the 3B working, compute 1% of output tax, and compare with the cash ledger balance a few days before you file.
  4. Deposit early. Cash challans can take time to reflect, particularly near the last date for the return.
  5. Track cumulative cash. If the cumulative test is your exception, keep a running statement of cash paid versus 1% of the total output tax liability.

What if you get it wrong?

If you short-pay cash because you have missed this rule, the shortfall is a short payment of tax. Interest runs from the statutory date, and a notice can follow. If the problem is found by the system or the officer, it will usually appear as a difference between liability reported and tax paid. The response is the same as for any short payment: pay the amount with interest, and document why it occurred. It is better to sort out a one-month error early than to carry it into an audit.

Why it ends up as a notice problem

Rule 86B is a payment mechanism, not a notice. But the first sign that it has been missed is often a short-payment demand, an interest charge or a portal prompt at filing time. Treat any of these as a signal to re-read the rule, not as a random error.

Practical checklist for a team handling many GSTINs

  • Add a column to your monthly checklist: "Taxable supplies above ₹50 lakh? Yes or No."
  • For each Yes, add a second column: "Exception applies? Which one and what evidence?"
  • Before filing, record the cash required and the date it was deposited.
  • Review the list quarterly, because turnover moves across the threshold during the year.
  • Record officer permissions, if any, in the business's file.

Summary

  • Above ₹50 lakh of monthly taxable supplies, ITC can pay at most 99% of output tax.
  • The balance 1% must come from the cash ledger, per GSTIN.
  • Exceptions exist for income tax payers, refund recipients, a cumulative cash test and government bodies.
  • Plan cash early and keep evidence for the exception you rely on.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Thresholds and exceptions are set by the rule as notified, so verify them before you file.

General information for professionals and businesses, not legal advice. GST law and portal behaviour change, so check the current notification or advisory before relying on a date, rate or threshold.

Keep every notice in one register

Read notices from the GST portal, give each to a person, track its stage and keep the notes with it, in Notice Management.